Reviews  |  Features  |  Photo Gallery  |  ShredRadio  |  Indie Reviews  |  Forums  |  Hall of Shame  |  Contact Us
 
 

C D  R e v i e w

  
Doctor Butcher - The Demos!!!
Crook'd Records
Overall Rating
The Breakdown
Shred
9
 
Production
9
 
Vibe
10
 
Songwriting
8
 
  

Who the hell is this? Savatage? Can't be. We all know the REAL Savatage ceased to exist when the great Criss Oliva tragically lost his life in 1993 (even earlier, some would argue). Who, then, could spawn such demonic howling and skull-smashing riffage? Why, Jon Oliva and Chris Caffery, aka Doctor Butcher, who else? This is the real deal, Metalheads! This CD is a collection of seven demos and two live tracks from the two former AND current members of the almighty Savatage! Don't be fooled by the word "demos" as this disc is better produced than many CD's you've paid big bucks for.

Opening cut "Freaks" makes it obvious that this is METAL Oliva-style as Jon is in classic form, belting it out over Caffery's power-crunch rhythms, bringing to mind the early days of "Sirens" and "The Dungeons Are Calling." The Mountain King (as Jon is affectionately referred to) goes over the top on the very amusing "Born of the Board" which starts with that familiar sounding piano and Lennonesque vocal, then explodes into a grinding assault of sonic savagery we haven't heard since…well, probably since the Doctor Butcher CD from '94! Check out the spoken part in the middle of the tune. Only Jon Oliva can get away with this kind of stuff these days! Classic. These songs have all the fire and heaviness that has sometimes been missing from recent Savatage. Not to blame the now departed Al Pitrelli, who is a great guitarist, but I can only hope that this is a taste of what's to come on the much anticipated Poets and Madmen due sometime in the next ten years from the Floridian metal madmen.

"Help, Police" is another scorcher in the classic mold and is sure to get a chuckle or two from the twist in the title's meaning. The next track is a demo version of "The Chair" from the first Butcher CD and is not quite as heavy, but very good, nevertheless. The darkness continues to fall on "Dismissal of Faith," a track that sees Caffery go for broke with some inspired neck-wringing. Awesome. A demo take of "The Altar" is included here, but can't hope to equal the brain-splattering glory of the "official" version. A somber tone is adopted for "Bridges," a song that mourns the ills of a society gone very wrong. Caffery shines on this track, firing off some brilliant, soulful fills throughout the tune. The two live tracks finish the disc and, while the sound quality is not on par with the studio material, these are welcome additions despite that. "Chester the Molester" is another lyrically amusing number in which Oliva calls the crowd "dirty motherfuckers"... a high compliment to be sure! Caffery goes CRAZY on this one! The fun comes to a close with "A Living Hell" a mid-tempo stomper full of blistering lead work from Mr. Caffery.

So, if you long for the power metal punch of classic Savatage, this is as close as you're going to get, kids. Crook'd records may still have some copies if you hurry to their site. Tell them who sent you. Until we "meat" again...

Reviewed by Nostradumbass

Get some fresh meat! Buy Doctor Butcher's The Demos!!! at

 

Copyright 1999-2000 Kevin Ryan/The House of Shred. All rights reserved. No part of this page may be reproduced without written permission of the Webmaster.