Reviews  |  Features  |  Photo Gallery  |  ShredRadio  |  Indie Reviews  |  Forums  |  Hall of Shame  |  Contact Us
 
 

C D  R e v i e w

  
Savatage - Poets And Madmen
Nuclear Blast Records
Overall Rating
The Breakdown
Shred
9
 
Production
10
 
Vibe
10
 
Songwriting
10
 
  

In the nearly four years since The Wake Of Magellan, a lot has transpired in the Savatage camp. First, the band made an amicable split from Atlantic Records, (remarkably) their US label since 1985's Power Of The Night, and signed with Nuclear Blast. Next came the departure of guitarist Al Pitrelli, who had, after years of hired-gun band-hopping, made Savatage his home for more than five years. But, alas the call was heard from the Marty Freidman-less Megadeth, and Al did go, saving the once mighty Mustaine-machine from the brink of alt-pop oblivion in the process. Next came the somewhat unexpected announcement from Zack Stevens that he, too, was jumping the Sava-ship. What remained was a stripped-down version of the Terror from Tampa, led once again by its patriarch, Jon Oliva with longtime cohort Chris Caffery the lone axe-slinger.

With Mentor/Producer/Co-writer/Zookeeper Paul O'Neill, the band entered New York's Soundtracks Studios with renewed purpose. What has resulted is not the ultra-heavy, straight-ahead power metal monster (think Dr. Butcher) that some expected, nor the slightly overblown theater-metal of recent efforts, but a very cool hybrid of the two that recalls the past while continuing to blaze new paths in modern progressive metal. While not a concept album in the true sense, Poets And Madmen is loosely based on a story penned by O'Neill and included in the liner notes. The story itself is deliberately vague and is something of a riddle, although it lacks enough real depth or relevance to make one actually care about solving it. (What the hell is up with the pseudo-Polaroid of a bikini-clad blonde? And what about the car keys?) Approximately four seconds into the disc, however, the weak premise is all but forgotten as the speakers slowly smolder with the piano and power chord intro to "Stay With Me Awhile," with Oliva doing his best Zack Stevens-does-Jon Oliva. Talk about coming full circle! It's a testament to the talents of Mr. Oliva that the band still sounds uniquely like Savatage, regardless of the various personnel changes the line-up has endured since the tragic death of Jon's brother, founding guitarist Criss Oliva, in 1993.

"There In The Silence" kicks off with, of all things, a synthesizer riff, before the rest of the band crashes the party and kicks it up a notch or three. Shades of vintage 'Tage color this tune with Caffery proving beyond any doubt that he is the rightful wielder of Excalibur.

A haunting, signature Jon Oliva piano introduces "Commissar," an epic in the vein of "Chance," "One Child" and "The Wake of Magellan." O'Neill's influence is apparent here in the neo-classical pomp and HUGE gang harmony vocals, until Caffery muscles in with a classic Sava-riff that has been somewhat MIA on the band's recent records. When he finally opens fire over said classic riff, it's all a fan could hope for and then some. Chris Caffery is one of the best guitarists in this genre and it's time he got the recognition he deserves. A major guitar magazine feature on the guitarists of Savatage is long overdue. (Hey, Guitar World, give me six or seven pages and I'll write the damn thing gratis!).

Next is the doom-cruncher "I Seek Power," a musical wrecking ball that sees Jon phase out of Zack mode momentarily and relive some of the glass-gargling glory of his earlier efforts. The ending of this song is pure metal bliss and I guarantee you'll be hitting rewind the second it's over! "Drive" is a catchy, uptempo track with cool harmony vocals that will coax the metal singer out of everyone that hears it. Caffery's lead break is superb as he displays some very impressive speed-picking and some of the most slithery legato this side of Ritchie Blackmore. The ten-minute centerpiece "Morphine Child" follows with one of the most infectious riffs these ears have heard in a long time. This track has something to satisfy every Savatage fan as it weaves from Oliva's melancholy piano and vocal to balls-out rifforama with their latter day trademark million-man singalong sandwiched between. Oh, and Caffery's guitar doesn't exactly grow mold on this track, either. The guy just plain smokes!

"The Rumor" begins with the surprising strum of acoustic guitar as the song's beleaguered narrator questions Jesus Christ about the state of mankind: "Jesus, would you then come down from your cross, return every nail and say we are lost?" Not for the faint-hearted, no siree! The rhythm section of drummer Jeff Plate and mainstay bassist Johnny Lee Middleton (most likely the bastard child of Geezer Butler) is the engine that propels the steamroller called "Man In The Mirror" and woe to those who would stand in their way! This is metal the way God intended: Dark... epic... heavy... kicking up the dust from the bottom of your soul and sending adrenaline raging through your veins!

"Surrender" comes woven with the kind of somber melody that could render the lyrics unnecessary, that is, if they weren't so thought provoking: "When in your life did you surrender, late in the night do you remember, what were the dreams that you betrayed then, would you go back if you could save them now?" This mournful tone gives way to a bludgeoning crunchfest that again reeks of the band's earlier work. "Awaken" continues this trend, conjuring such classic tracks as "Beyond The Doors Of The Dark" and "Jesus Saves."

For years, Savatage lyrics have had an uncommon duality in that they are usually part of an elaborate story, yet remain poignant and self-inclusive when detached from the whole. This can certainly be said about the introspective closing track, "Back to a Reason." Oliva is in fine vocal form here. Hell, this guy could sing the ingredients on a Doritos bag and leave you scrambling to reassess your life by the sheer conviction and sincerity of his delivery. Although O'Neill has authored most, if not all, of the group's lyrics since Streets, I often wonder if his muse is Jon Oliva himself.

This album marks another turning point in the unpredictable career of this exceptional band. Like Lynyrd Skynyrd and Def Leppard, they have managed to rise from the depths of tragedy to soar high on the wings of perseverance. And somewhere in Headbanger Heaven, you just know there's an angel with a white Charvel watching it all with a smile.

Shred Pick: "Morphine Child"

Reviewed by Chris Yancik

Click here to buy Savatage - Poets And Madmen from

Click here to buy Savatage - Poets And Madmen from

  

Copyright 1999-2000 Kevin Ryan/The House of Shred. All rights reserved. No part of this page may be reproduced without written permission of the Webmaster.